According to Forbes, I graduated from the 5th best college in America. =)
It’s about time college rankings were measured by its students & graduates’ contribution to the public good.
Forbes completely rails on Washington Monthly’s non-conventional college rankings.
I don’t fully agree with either side. I applaud Washington Monthly’s attempt to recognize colleges for their societal benefit, but I agree with Forbes that the criteria is lacking. It’s great to provide opportunities to low-income students, but their admission/graduation alone does not necessarily lead to a greater society. How many of those graduates go on to use their education in skilled jobs? It begs the question, what is a college degree really worth nowadays?
On the other side, I think Forbes discounts this generation’s genuine desire to see a better world. The author says the ivy league history grad would gladly take a corporate job over the peace corp if the job was available. Not speaking as an ivy league grad, but I think that’s an unfair blanket statement.
Good article to get you thinking more critically about rankings, though…
Source: krysjill
first few paragraphs, then blogged...haven’t had the chance to read it in its entirety, so...
Very interesting read. It’s not a Forbes ranking, it’s a Washington Monthly ranking. With some valid points and...
Forbes completely rails on Washington Monthly’s non-conventional college rankings.I don’t fully agree with either side....